“I would like you to do us a favor though . . . “

Earlier today President Trump released a summary memorandum of his July 2019 call with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Its contents are damning. They justify Trump’s impeachment, without question. 

The summary — which it should be remembered, was crafted by Trump and his aides in order to put Trump’s words and conduct in the best possible light — clearly shows Trump using his powers as Commander-in-Chief and Head of State to pressure a foreign actor into doing his domestic political bidding. 

The critical context: Ukraine faces an existential threat from Russia, with which it has been in a virtual — and sometimes active — state of war for some time. Russia has annexed a portion of Ukraine and represents a constant military threat. In light of that, Ukraine desperately depends on foreign military aid, particularly from the United States. 

In the call, Zelensky butters up Trump to no end, both personally and about how grateful he is for our help. He also plays into Trump’s need to feel superior to other leaders and leans hard into how little help, comparatively, Ukraine receives from Germany and France, mentioning its leaders by name, as Trump is wont to do. Trump laps that up and then leans back into Zelensky, agreeing how important our military aid is to Ukraine’s security. 

It is against that backdrop that Zelensky makes his ask for FGM-148 Javelin missiles, which are  essential for Ukraine in the event of a Russian invasion: 


​Trump’s immediate response: 

“I would like you to us a favor though.”

Words mean things and the “though” is the smoking gun.

In this passage, Trump is putting an express condition on United States military aid to Ukraine: sure, we’ll help you, but you need to help me in combatting my domestic political enemies.

​The reference to investigating the “whole situation in Ukraine” and Crowdstrike, refers to the company hired to investigate the hack of the Democratic National Committee during the 2016 election. Trump went on to mention the “other thing.” What other thing?


Here Trump is, plainly, asking Zelensky to look into unsubstantiated allegations against Hunter Biden, the son of the potential Democratic nominee.

​Trump is asking for political dirt. He is doing so by using Zelensky’s obvious desire for military aid as a lever. It could not be any more clear.

​It’s a shakedown, in which Trump is using his defense and foreign policy powers to aid his political prospects. And, again, it should be noted that this is via Trump’s own, self-interested summary memorandum of the conversation. The surrounding context, other conversations, acts in furtherance of this initial exchange, and whatever else exists illuminating all of this likely casts it in a worse light. 

President Trump has abused his power. His doing so is an impeachable offense. It could not be any more clear.

UPDATE: The Whistleblower Complaint has been released and it is damning

Craig Calcaterra

Craig is the national baseball writer for NBCSports.com. He writes about things other than sports at Craigcalcaterra.com. He lives in New Albany, Ohio with his wife, two kids, and many cats.